A simple observation on the nature of law and government
Published Fri, Aug 22 2008 8:13 PM
It occurs to me that there's a simple way to determine whether or not a person truly believes in liberty and freedom or not. Simply observe whether they believe that we need more laws to regulate behavior, speech, or not. Simply observe whether they support more or larger government programs or not. This isn't a foolproof measure of a person's love for liberty, but it's likely to be a good indicator.
It seems to me that the intent of most laws is to restrict the ability to act in certain ways. Failure to abide by the restrictions of law typically carries a penalty. Well, that's usually the case.
In some cases, laws are necessary for the protection of society. They restrict actions that would in general be detrimental to society. For example, most people (although certainly not all people) would probably agree that a person that intentionally kills another person is a danger to society. Because of this, we have laws that make the intentional killing of another person a criminal act and that specify punishment for it — usually the removal of the killer from society, either by imprisonment or execution.
In other cases, laws are not necessary for the protection of society. Rather, they restrict actions that would in general be beneficial to society. I can think of quite a few such laws, although I'm sure that a good many people would argue against my contention that these laws are detrimental to our society. For example, most people in the United States (at least according to recent polls) believe that it is a good idea to try to locate and extract petroleum from domestic sources, and yet we have laws that prohibit doing this very thing.
Ask yourself a simple question. “What does government produce?” Each time I ask myself this question, I cannot name a single beneficial thing to answer it. On the other hand, I can think of a great many examples where our government restricts production.
Let's make it more specific shall we? Does government produce medicines? Does it produce computers? Does it produce airplanes? Does it produce food? Does it produce cell phones, electronics, cars, air conditioners, furnaces, stoves, refrigerators, light bulbs (especially those compact fluorescent that are being mandated by governments), toilet paper, or any of the other things that we use every day? Government produces none of these things. They are all, each and every one of them produced by private enterprises.
Does government perform surgeries? Does it mount and balance your tires and insure their proper inflation? Does it tune your car for you? Does it refine fuel and put it in your gas tank? Does it harvest the crops that you eat? Does government serve your meals in a restaurant? Does it wash the dishes or bus your table? Does government keep a convenience store operating into the night so that you can make those last minute late night purchases? Government performs none of these services for you. They are all, each and every one of them performed by private individuals.
Every one of these products and services is regulated by government. Government taxes them all.
Consider this, if the government takes over health care, they still won't produce the medications. If the government takes over health care, they still won't perform the diagnoses or the surgeries. But they will ration them. If the government takes over health care, there won't be more of it available, there will be less of it available.
Government doesn't produce things, it regulates and restricts access to them. Government doesn't create efficiencies it creates inefficiencies. Laws don't create liberties, laws restrict liberties. Even our Constitution imposes restrictions — restrictions on our government.
We need laws to restrain those people in our society that would harm others. We need some of the services that our government is responsible for, such as defense, and a unified foreign policy. Our Constitution provides the power to provide those services to the federal government. Our Constitution provides the States with the powers to make laws to handle our social needs. But it also restricts the federal government from doing a great many things that are detrimental to our society.
At least, that's what the framers intended. Consider your candidates for local office. Consider your candidates for state office. Consider your candidates for the House of Representatives and the Senate in our federal government. Consider the candidates for the Presidency. Consider carefully the initiatives that might appear on your ballot. Consider all of these things and ask yourself this question — “If I and my fellow voters make this choice, will it enhance or restrict my liberties? If I and my fellow voters make this choice, how will it affect not just us and our generation, but how will it affect the liberties and opportunities of generations to follow?”
Consider those questions carefully. And vote your conscience.
This linkfest is for the 22nd, 23rd, and 24th of August, 2008. If you have something interesting you'd like to share, feel free to link it here and leave a trackback. Just remember the trackback policy.
For the best exposure, go to the blogger's oasis and use the linkfest chooser to choose the posts you'd like to hook up with.
Trackback URI for this post: http://perrinelson.com/track.aspx?postid=1230
Permalink URI for this post: http://perrinelson.com/2008/8/22/1230.aspx
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Obama picks a fairly un-fresh VP, tells Hillary to keep the ‘change’"
Obama and his flock of acolytes have consistently portrayed him as the younger, hipper candidate. The candidate of change. The fresh wind in the sour air of politics, the new voice. Someone not a part of politics as usual.
They h...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (23 Aug 08) Obama/Biden Edition"
“I mean, you’ve got the first sort of mainstream African-American who is articulate and bright and clean and a nice-looking guy. I mean, that’s a story-book, man,” Biden on Obama a few months back. Now he’s your boss stupid.
A First Lo...
Shadowscope trackbacked with "Caylee Anthony Updates III"
I've stepped back a bit the last couple of days and haven't really written much about Caylee Anthony or her mother Casey, who is now out on bail. There hasn't been a single useful bit of news to come out...
Conservative Cat trackbacked with "A Whole Day of Journalists Going Nuts and We End Up With Biden"
I'll say this for Senator Obama: he may have trouble answering questions about abortion, but he knows how to hold the attention of the mainstream press. Every 30 minutes for an entire day the top news story was that Barack...
The World According To Carl trackbacked with "Godly Wisdom — August 23, 2008"
Hang On To What God Says To You
...
The Amboy Times trackbacked with "Exclusive: Biden's VP Interview"
In an Amboy Times Exclusive, our roving reporter Shemp Davis eavesdrops on what we believe to be the initial interview of Sen Joe Biden for Democratic nominee for Vice President.
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "Take This Quiz Now"
Or you suck.
At one of my favorite lefty blogs I was trying to see what was going on “over the fence” regarding the Barack America/Joe Biden ticket and found something that will help you waste appx. 2 minutes of your day.
The Political Comp...
123beta trackbacked with ""Every Bit Of My Love""
Political correctness runs amuck (again):Organizers of the London 2012 Games commissioned the band's (Zeppelin) guitarist Jimmy Page to record a new version of the song (Whole Lotta Love) to be perfor...
Rosemary's Thoughts trackbacked with "I can't think of a bloody thing to say"
I've been searching and researching, and I can't think of a bloody thing to say in time to meet my private deadline that I set for myself. So I am going to have an Open Trackback Party. At Rosemary's News and Ideas is where you link back to me
third world county trackbacked with "Fraudian Slip?"
Loose lips or
SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: "", url: "" });...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (24 Aug 08)"
SPEAKING DEMOCRAT - Government = Socialism - There’s a link to the video explaining it all. Kinda dry but hats off to Rep. Thad McCotter(R-MI)) for having the balls to get on the house floor and say it.
Sunday Funnies from Flopping Aces
Local ...
Planck's Constant trackbacked with "Russian Invasion of Georgia and Deja Vu"
I blame the Russian invasion on Liberal idiots who have so demoralized this country that Russia now thinks it can do anything it wants because we have no stomach to defend our allies.
Woman Honor Thyself trackbacked with "ObamA, Biden, Germany and SwastikaS"
If Hussein Obama and his sidekick Biden have their way, America will become a one size fits all whipping boy for every negative obsession spewing forth from the EU.
...
The Virtuous Republic trackbacked with "Doonesbury: Worst Comic Ever"
Today’s Doonesbury exemplifies the simplified, emotional, illogical, childlike belief system and thought process of the left.
Unending war? Where does one start? Does the left think anything good would happen if we ran from Iraq? Even if one ...
Right Truth Two trackbacked with "Right Truth Two - open for business"
Dear gentle readers, as many of you know TypePad has been making many changes lately, especially to it's compose editor. There have been many improvements, but many bugs still exist. So on certain days Right Truth may be slow in posting, slow in load...
Right Truth Two trackbacked with "Right Truth Two - open for business"
Dear gentle readers, as many of you know TypePad has been making many changes lately, especially to it's compose editor. There have been many improvements, but many bugs still exist. So on certain days the ORIGINAL Right Truth may be slow in posting,...
Right Voices trackbacked with "Brutal: New ad hammers Obama over Ayers"
This will leave a mark!
Was this one set to roll today all along or was it in the chamber and ready to fire in case Obama tried a guilt-by-association ploy of his own first? Either way, acidic stuff. Ben Smith has background on the group that produ...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (25 Aug 08)"
Russia warns Moldova against “Georgian mistake”
America’s New Breed of Traitors - Public Schools, Business World and the Government
Somewhere in America a butterfly is dead, and it’s George Bush’s fault.
Party for Socialism ...
Woman Honor Thyself trackbacked with "Lyse Doucet: TalibaN Barbarians DefendeR"
Next thing ya know, Lyse will be thrusting herself upon the moral high ground, with her Lefty, freedom bashing buddies by claiming American culture is decadent and that, of course— the reason we got attacked on Sept 11 is that Muzlims, the Talis and ...
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "As another Boeing strike looms, I wonder: Does Boeing want the strike?"
Washington has a plethora of industry, but there are two names that pretty much come to people's minds when they think of the state: Boeing and Microsoft. I have worked for both, and while I have mentioned my high tech industry experiences, I don't...
Cao's Blog trackbacked with "Biden; Waco; Vicki & Sammy Weaver at Ruby Ridge"
oe Biden wholeheartedly supported the actions of federal agents in the Waco standoff, and visibly sneered at witnesses at the Senate hearings who questioned and/or criticized the agents’ acts.
...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (26 Aug 08)"
News of the day…
All Eyes on Clinton After Michelle Obama Charms Denver - You already know how I feel about Michelle’s speech.
Baron, wife and firm gave nearly $7 million, analysis shows
Barack Obama through Muslim Eyes
Muslim and Maldivia...
Mark My Words trackbacked with "Reasoned discourse"
Or, how to show your man boobs in public. ...
Right Voices trackbacked with "Could You Send Some Linky Love To My Nephews?"
Here is the deal, they are 10 and 8. Neither are not politically motivated, nor are they (you can use the adjective of your choice here) like me and did I mention that they are 10 and 8!?!?! They started a WordPress blog about Club Penquin called...
Woman Honor Thyself trackbacked with "100 CaloriE TreatS"
Sooooooooo……….Are there really any shortcuts to losing weight?
...
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Democrats, Catholics and abortion"
OK, I admit, that title almost reads like some lame joke lead in ( a priest and abortionist and a democrat walked into a bar and.....).
But believe it or not, it is news. Now, as a disclaimer, I am not promoting a stand on abortion here, this is mer...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (27 Aug 08)"
News of the day…
Convention Cheat Sheet: Unite the Clans!
Complete Idiots Guide to Obama’s Socialism
Muslims Outraged Over Film ‘Towelhead’
Pelosi and Hoyer No Match for Thinking People
Announcing: Exciting Changes for Ft. Hard Kn...
Mark My Words trackbacked with "Who covers up good news?"
Politicians certainly don't, especially when it's about them. What then should be thought of a politician who uses strong arm tactics and attempts to bring down the power of the federal government on someone over a video? ...
Conservative Cat trackbacked with "Obama's Image Problem."
A Hillary Clinton supporter is suing the DNC on the grounds that Barack Obama is not a U.S. citizen. Meanwhile, the Obama campaign is suing to block an ad linking the Senator with a former terrorist. It's lawsuit time as...
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Pelosi and Biden unrepentant about Abortion"
Both Pelosi and Biden who were chastised by Catholic Archbishops for their prolife stances show no signs of contrition, and continue to insist their positions are not controversial.
First, Biden, who claims that his beliefs may not be in line, but it...
Cao's Blog trackbacked with "12 Americans are murdered every day by illegal aliens"
If those numbers are correct, it translates to 4,380 Americans murdered annually by illegal aliens – more than the U.S. death toll of soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan combined. That’s more than 30,000 Americans killed by illegal aliens since Se...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (28 Aug 08)"
News of the day…
The angels sang, the heavens parted and the hand of G-D came down from the clouds and anointed the chosen one. It’s unanimous: Democrats nominate Obama by acclamation
To which the evil Satan had this response.
Army Vet...
Mark My Words trackbacked with "Class vs the old politics"
uite a few hours before Obama gave his acceptance speech, the McCain campaign released this video. ...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "News & Opinion Roundup (29 Aug 08)"
McCains Veep choice should be announced today and give us scamps some relief wondering who it will be. The rumor mills are counting out Romney and Pawlenty already this morning and this article focuses on Hutchinson. Me personally, if your going to...
The Amboy Times trackbacked with "Gaddafi's Son: Lockerbie relatives "very greedy""
It's difficult to even imagine the horror of losing a loved one to a terrorist act. To think that someone you cared for so deeply was erased from this world just so Gaddafi could made a political/religious statement.
Subscribe to this entry's
comment feed. (Atom)
Angel responded with:
 | your first two lines say it all perri!!:) |
David responded with:
 | Hmmm... I'd add another test. If a person believes in the fundamental right of a citizen to resist tyranny by force of arms, then they are likely someone who has a strong committment to liberty. OTOH, if a person believes that citizens should be disarmed and subject to the whime of government thugs (as well as "NGO"--or unofficial criminals, *heh*), I'd say that person deserves to have their liberties restricted by those same thugs. |
Perri Nelson responded with:
 | Yes, that test is another good one. I don't think we're quite to the point where that's necessary yet, but if things continue to go the way they are, we may well be within another generation or so. |
Layla responded with:
 | I think your first two lines, as Angel said say it all. David also makes a good case for his test too.
Personally, I keep it simple - you either love this nation or not. You are either a patriot or a pinhead. The rest in between really is all dung. |
Diane responded with:
 | So you still believe that voting actually matters?
LMAO |
Perri Nelson responded with:
| Of course I believe that voting actually matters. It saddens me that you do not. |
Wingless responded with: duh...
 | DIANE said
So you still believe that voting actually matters?
LMAO
Everyone knows the New World Order & the Elders of Zion handpick a president based on birthmarks fortold by Illumaniti 'see-ers'; like, duhhh...
Seriously though - in this election 'voting', that is - "getting the people out to vote" - may be the DECIDING FACTOR! Barring unforseen scandals or gaffes by either side, this election will remain so close that the side that better succeeds in getting people out to vote on election day is the side that will win.
In elections as close as this one every vote trully does count - hopefully the Republicans appreciate this and can mobilize a massive grassroots effort to get people into the voting booth come November. |
Wingless responded with:
| Hi Perri (or Mr. Nelson :-|),
I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong in terms of tracking back to this post. If you go to: http://wingless.aoriginality.com/?p=190
you will see that I tried to manually trackback but alas, it didn't succeed as I did not recieve a reciprocal trackback...
What am I doing wrong?
BTW: I'm using the hosted (installed on my own webspace) version of Wordpress.
Sorry for posting here, I could not find a contact button - feel free to delete.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated,
Wingless |