Where else but in a court of law
Published Mon, Jun 30 2008 9:00 AM
Where else but in a court of law could logical fallacies rise to the level of evidence? Especially in capital cases? Last Friday, I ran across this Associated Press article in the Seattle Times.
Saami Shaibani often testified for the prosecution in big murder cases, taking the stand as an expert in what he called "injury mechanism analysis" - a combination of physics, trauma medicine and engineering that he used to determine whether, say, a woman fell down the stairs or was beaten.
But after years of helping lock up killers, Shaibani could be the one in trouble.
The physicist lied under oath about his credentials, and now some of the convictions he helped secure are in jeopardy. At least one has been overturned so far.
His testimony has come under attack in at least five cases from Washington, D.C., to South Dakota since Shaibani was caught lying when he claimed that he was a clinical associate professor at Temple University and that he taught doctors there about injuries.
"He's a fraud. Basically, he was trying to create himself as an expert so he could run around the country and testify in these cases," said Wisconsin lawyer Stephen Willett.
And of course, that's one of the big problems with the appeal to authority, a logical fallacy that all too often gets a pass in our courtrooms. After all, it's often on the testimony of "experts" that people are convicted of murder or other crimes. While it may be true that a person is actually guilty despite the credibility of the witnesses for or against them, it's dangerous to rely on fallacies when a person's life is on the line.
An appeal to authority is when you rely upon the assertion of a person you judge to be an authority to support your argument. While an authority may speak the truth about the matter, they may also assert a falsehood. Further, simply because a person is judged to be an authority doesn't make them one, and they may not be an authority on the subject matter at hand.
In this case, we have a clear example of someone being judged to be an authority based upon false credentials. The standard of proof for a conviction in a criminal case is meant to be "beyond a reasonable doubt." Further, the burden of proof is upon the prosecution.
In recent years, we've seen false claims of authority. We've seen "expert" witnesses testify to mutually exclusive sets of "facts". We've watched as forensics laboratories have been found to have falsified their test results. Considering these examples, and the falsified credentials of Saami Shaibani, how can we let stand convictions based solely upon "expert" testimony?
It seems to me that there's a lot of room for "reasonable doubt" whenever a conviction turns on such "evidence". If a so-called expert is willing to lie about his credentials, what else is he willing to lie about?
Saami Shaibani may have believed that his intentions were good. I think that they were evil regardless of his belief. How many innocent people were convicted of heinous crimes because of his foul deeds? And how many people's faith in our system of justice has forever been tarnished by a man whose main employment was "helping an older man write down orders for his plumbing business"?
Logical fallacies have no place as evidence in criminal cases. Saami Shaibani is proof enough of that. But while we're considering the appeal to authority, let's not fall prey to the fallacist's fallacy either. Just because this so-called expert without a moral center has tainted the cases he's been involved with doesn't exonerate his victims. Some were convicted on evidence other than his testimony. For the rest, they deserve new trials, complete with the presumption of innocence. And if there's sufficient real evidence to convict them then their convictions should stand.
This linkfest is for the 30th of June, 2008.
If you have something interesting you'd like to share, feel free to link it here and leave a trackback.
Just remember the trackback policy.
For the best exposure, go to the blogger's oasis and use the linkfest chooser to choose the posts you'd like to hook up with.
Trackback URI for this post: http://perrinelson.com/track.aspx?postid=1187
Permalink URI for this post: http://perrinelson.com/2008/6/30/1187.aspx
Right Truth trackbacked with "Terrorism, Religion, Obama, and America"
Barack Obama, when elected President of the United States of America, wants to use foreign troops in the American military, specifically Ugandans. Aurora reports, "In all fairness, the recruitment process has already been taking some unconventional turns lately as the Dearborn military recruitment center turns to recruiting non-citizen Muslims (June, 2008)"
walls of the city trackbacked with "i never would have guessed"
I hope Mr. Michael van der Galien does not mind, but this article definitely deserves quoting in its entirety: It’s really quite simple: gun control legislation did not reduce violence. Secondly, people started actually reading the text of the second...
Beagle Scout trackbacked with "1.2 Million Have signed Drill Here, Drill Now, Pay Less"
In the previous post I urged you to sign a petition for H. R. 3089. In this one I urge you to sign another petition that just might help with energy.
Drill Here.
Drill Now.
Pay Less.
...
Adam's Blog trackbacked with "Supporters in Glass Houses"
Podcast Show Notes
Wesley Clark cluelessly attacks John McCain’s executive experience (did he forget who he was supporting.)
Barack Obama delivers a slick speech on patriotism.
A pro-life 527 forms to tell the truth about Obama’s support ...
Conservative Cat trackbacked with "Crazy Obama Rumors Need to be Stopped"
Today on the Laura Ingraham radio show (I've missed saying that), she discussed this article in the Washington Post. The article discusses false rumors about Barack Obama and features interviews with people who believe them. I have always had a...
Diary of the Mad Pigeon trackbacked with "Taking the Boy Fishing"
One of my New Year's resolutions was to take the Monkey fishing--and that's just what I did this past Saturday. I hadn't fished since... man, 1987, 1988? It's been a long time. Once an avid angler, I simply gave up
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Is Obama our most well known illegal alien?"
Yes I know I have gone a few weeks. I've been sick. Sue me.
Topping today's blogs: Is Obama even a US citizen? Are we coming close to electing the Illegal Alien in Chief?
It sounds like a joke, and initially I dismissed...
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Are blogs the criticize Obama being shut down deliberately? Yes."
Yes indeed, it is clearly happening, that fact is not being disputed. The only real question is "by who". This, by the way I regard as a serious issue. I left Blogger 3 years ago to give my blog more creative control and security...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "NEWS & OPINION ROUNDUP (1 JULY 2008) THE JOE HORN EDITION"
Score one for the good guys! Joe Horn, the Texas man made famous via a 911 call as his neighbors house was being robbed has been cleared of any criminal charges. BLAM!… I’ll bet there hasn’t been a robbery in that ne...
Right Voices trackbacked with "10 Months After “General Betray Us”, Obama Denounces MoveOn"
“A general providing his best counsel on how to move forward in Iraq was accused of betrayal. “We can no longer afford these sorts of divisions.”
Did this just dawn on him? What made him have a change of heart? Remember Obama walk...
The World According To Carl trackbacked with "Godly Wisdom — July 2, 2008"
Work Hard And Wisely And You Will Avoid Poverty
...
The Virtuous Republic trackbacked with "Harry Reid Says Coal and Oil Makes Us Sick"
Here you have it, the far American left is finally letting its true agenda show. And in this case, we see that Harry Reid, Senate Majority Leader from Nevada, has drunk the liberal, kook, environmental kool-aid on oil.
The American left doesn’t ...
The World According To Carl trackbacked with "Where The Hell Is Matt?"
The above video is the end result of a project by Matthew Harding who spent 14 months visiting 42 countries in order to produce "Where The Hell Is Matt?", in which Harding performed an incredibly silly dance in various places around the world. He even ...
Woman Honor Thyself trackbacked with "Doozie of the DaY: Reuters"
But not to denounce Izlamic worldwide terrorism. Don’t be silly.
They are busy challenging what they call “Izlamophobia”. What a brave undertaking, dontcha think?
...
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Harry Reid followed by Dennis Miller on Harry Reid"
Ok, this guy is at best and out of touch divisive idiot who has completely lost touch with reality, commonsense and truth. He is clueless, dim and laughable.
Why Nevada keeps electing him is a bona fide mystery.
Here he is bloviating ho...
Democrat=Socialist trackbacked with "NEWS & OPINION ROUNDUP (2 JULY 2008) THE "BLACK NATIONAL ANTHEM" EDITION"
Denver’s City Council president is getting hammered with hate-filled messages in response to Tuesday’s surprise performance of the "Black National Anthem" by a jazz singer during a city event. You can contact him and let him...
Subscribe to this entry's
comment feed. (Atom)
Angel responded with:
 | logic?..whats that? Heh :) |
Mustang responded with:
 | It is fundamental to our system of justice that every person accused of a crime is innocent until proved guilty. The burden to prove guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt” rests entirely with the government. When government relies on so-called “expert testimony” to gain a conviction, and it is later revealed that the witness is a sham, then the government “cheated” the defendants out of a fair trial.
I agree every conviction should be overturned and the accused retried; it is a fair sanction if we cherish a system that presumes innocence and demands government prove its case. More than this, someone should be looking into the mechanism that allowed a phony to be “certified” as an expert witness; if it is learned that false certification was no mere oversight, then we should be reading about another trial. |
Layla responded with:
 | What logic? There seems to be quite a lack of it these days. So sad.
Happy Independence Day to you and yours Perri from me and mine! |