Disasters, natural and otherwise
Published Fri, Oct 26 2007 9:49 AM
Technorati Tags: News and Politics
"It's Bush's fault." That's what we were hearing this week about the California wildfires. They were exacerbated due to global warming, which wouldn't be happening if President Bush made us implement the Kyoto Protocol we were told. The disaster response wasn't fast enough. California's national guard troops were all over in Iraq. California's national guard equipment was over in Iraq.
We now know that global warming had little or nothing to do with the wildfires that seem to happen every year in southern California. We now know that the Santa Ana winds that helped to spread the wildfires happen every year, and that there's nothing unusual about how dry those winds were.
Federal relief efforts began within a day of the disaster. California has 20,000 active national guard troops and only 2,000 of them are overseas. The other 18,000 are still in California. Not only that but California actually has more equipment than they can use, both their own, and that supplied by the federal government and from other states.
It also turns out that the wildfires were set. That's right, it was arson. Several arson suspects are in custody, but the last I heard none of them had been linked to the wildfires yet.
About the only thing I've heard about poor response had to do with state regulations regarding the helicopters used to scoop up water from rivers and dump it on fires. Apparently they had to have spotter planes as escorts and that caused delays. State officials though have said that bureaucracy did not get in the way of the response, it was just high winds that made it dangerous to fly.
As I was driving home from work last night, I was listening to re-runs of some of the day's talk radio shows. I had the opportunity to listen to an exchange between Gov. Schwarzenegger and a reporter. She kept pushing him to find something wrong with the federal response, but he was having none of it.
The latest news I've heard on this is that six people are dead, millions have been evacuated and thousands of homes and businesses have been destroyed by the fires. That's a horror and a tragedy of huge proportions.
I've been very fortunate in my life not to have suffered anything like the loss the people in southern California are facing. I've never lost a home to fire, flood, earthquake or any other natural disaster. In fact I've never lost a home.
I can only imagine how devastating it would be though. Even with insurance, replacing or rebuilding the home could be an incredible setback. While rebuilding is going on living in a hotel, a stadium, or shelter would be horrifying. The irreplaceable memories held within small possessions such as photo albums, nick-knacks and the like would be gone forever.
Every time I hear about a tragedy such as the wildfires in California, or hurricanes devastating entire communities (remember Andrew?) it hurts a bit inside to think of what the people are going through.
Starting over would be tough. This is why we have insurance programs. This is why we have disaster relief programs. This is one reason why we have zoning regulations and building codes.
Natural disasters happen. We can do a lot of things to mitigate the dangers, but we can't eliminate them.
People that live on mountainsides are always at risk of landslides taking their house downhill. People that live on beaches are always at risk of having storm surge erode the sand under their homes. People that live on islands are at risk of tsunamis washing their homes away. People that live in "basins" like New Orleans are at risk of floods. People that live in dry wooded areas are in danger of wildfire. People that live near volcanoes… well, you get the idea.
Oftentimes in the wake of these tragedies I'll read some rather strange responses. On the left we have Bush Derangement Syndrome trying to blame every natural catastrophe on the President, and eagerly looking to find mistakes in the response. On the right, it's often some callous remark like "who in their right mind builds their house on a flood plain?".
Both responses are wrong-headed.
As you know, I'm all for smaller government. I believe that a lot of the programs that our federal government gets involved in, such as welfare, social security and medicare aren't rightly its business. Disaster preparedness and response are an exception though. While the primary responsibility for these still belongs at the state and local levels, the federal government should be involved in them as well.
The Constitution grants the Congress the power to "lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States". I believe that the "general Welfare of the United States" most definitely includes disaster preparedness and response.
It makes sense in the wake of a disaster to examine the federal response, because the federal government has a constitutional duty to see to the general welfare of the United States. The comparisons between the federal response to the California wildfires and the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina aught to be made. We need to know whether we've learned from previous disasters and whether we're handling them better or worse.
We shouldn't focus all of our attention on the federal response though. As I said earlier, the primary responsibility for preparedness and response still belongs at the state and local level. This is simply common sense.
Think about it. If you're at home, cooking dinner and a grease fire starts and quickly spreads, do you wait for the fire department to arrive before responding? Or do you grab some flour and throw it on the fire to smother it?
If an earthquake topples a building and people are trapped under the rubble, should you wait for the federal government to bring in heavy equipment to move that rubble, or should you use local equipment. If you wait, it's almost certain that more lives will be lost than if you respond quickly.
Politicians, the media, and bloggers love to play the blame game.
In California the blame was quickly thrown upon President Bush, for things that had little or nothing to do with how events unfolded. It turns out though that the local, state, and the federal response was quick. It also turns out that the blame for the horrifying tragedy that has unfolded belongs to a sick, twisted individual that deliberately set the fires.
In Louisiana the blame was quickly thrown upon President Bush. The news media were all over the story, hyping things up and reporting on events that never actually happened. How many of you remember the reports of cannibalism and rape gangs? The federal government response was criticized and called racist. Who remembers the parking lot full of busses sitting in water? Busses that the local government could have used to evacuate?
Why is it that a category 3 hurricane is treated as an example of the effects of global warming? Why is it that nobody compares Katrina to Andrew, the second most destructive hurricane in U.S. History and a category 5 storm? Could it be that it's harder to play the "race card" with Andrew?
Few people have remarked upon or contrasted the effects that Katrina had in Mississippi with the effects on New Orleans. Both were hit by the same storm. There was severe damage in both places. Could it be that the effectiveness of the response and the preparedness of the government in Mississippi weren't newsworthy, and the poor response and lack of preparation in Louisiana made the perfect opportunity to castigate the President?
The big differences in the California wildfire story and the Katrina story were the local response, and the treatment of the federal response by the media.
The blame game needs to be put back in the box and the box needs to be put back on the shelf. Preferably in the back.
Which is more important anyway? The tragedy suffered by the victims of these catastrophes, both natural and unnatural, or the political opportunities they provide for politicians more interested in power than people?
Cross posted at NW Bloggers and Bloggers for Civil Discourse.
This linkfest is for the 26th, 27th, and 28th of October, 2007.
If you have something interesting you'd like to share, feel free to link it here and leave a trackback.
Just remember the trackback policy.
For the best exposure, go to the blogger's oasis and use the linkfest chooser to choose the posts you'd like to hook up with.
Trackback URI for this post: http://perrinelson.com/track.aspx?postid=1036
Permalink URI for this post: http://perrinelson.com/2007/10/26/1036.aspx
Stuck On Stupid trackbacked with "Democrats, The Party Of Amygdala?"
According to The Hill Democrats have a difficult time relaying their messages to the average voter. A more comprehensive message is needed to sufficiently relay Democrat Party talking points to the electorate. Democrats feel that they ha...
Blog @ MoreWhat.com trackbacked with "HillaryGate, HillaryScam or JustHillary"
One needs a template to simplify posting of Clinton stories to include the dirty laundry list of sordid scenarios that have not, to date, resulted in convictions.
...
planck's constant trackbacked with "Blogrush is run by Idiots"
The other day I got an email from Blogrush dropping my site from their listings
A Blog For All trackbacked with "Fort Dix Six Defendant To Enter Guilty Plea"
This plea deal may lead Abdullahu to flip on his co-defendants, which bodes poorly for the other five defendants. It also adds to the pressure on the other five to try and cut deals for themselves.
Wolf Pangloss trackbacked with "If Dollars Grew in Diapers"
Barack Obama has a remarkably young donor base. Let’s have a poem!
...
The Amboy Times trackbacked with "Murder Attempts at SIOE Demonstration"
Muslim terrorists unwittingly make SIOE's point by reacting violently to a peaceful protest. Hat tip, JW.Sunday the 21th October was not only a severe attack on freedom of speech but an attempt to close the mouth forever on an organisation
Shadowscope trackbacked with "Saturday PhotoHunt: Pink"
It's funny. Although she's all girl, Pete has never really been into the frilly pink stuff. Her sister is another story altogether. 90% of the clothing she owns is pink and if given a choice she ALWAYS chooses pink. Thus...
Rosemary's Thoughts trackbacked with "TGIF OTB"
Today is Friday, and I haven't a thing to say. Well, that's not exactly true...It's as if everyone disappeared except for the people who actually read what I wrote over at Rosemary's Thoughts.com. I'M NOT THERE ANYMORE. I am at Rosemary's Thoughts.bl...
Pirate's Cove trackbacked with "Silky Hates Free Speech"
Let’s see, how does that go?
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and ...
The Florida Masochist trackbacked with "The Knucklehead of the Day award"
Today's winner is FEMA.
Stuck On Stupid trackbacked with "Condi Rice Confers With Carter & Clinton On Mideast Peace Parley"
Secretary Of State Condolezza Rice has conferred with Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton on Mideast Talks. Getting advice from Jimmy Carter on Israel is akin to asking Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for solutions to the Mideast conflicts. Rice h...
Big Dogs Weblog trackbacked with "Open Trackback Post October 26th"
This is an open trackback post. I just got in from Utah and do not feel like writing anything so have at it.
Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Perri Nelson’s Website, , Right Truth, Stix Blog, The Populist, Shadowscope, The A...
universityupdate.com trackbacked with "Disasters, natural and otherwise"
The Uncooperative Blogger trackbacked with "The Uncooperative Radio Show! October. 27 and 28"
We finally got our internet back!
Live, Independent, Conservative Talk Radio! We are rocking every Friday, Saturday and Sunday 8pm to 10pm Eastern Time. All shows recorded and archived.
www.uncooperativeradio.com
I will be talking about import...
Leaning Straight Up trackbacked with "Another reason I like Fred! Thompson"
Here is yet another reason to like Fred! Thompson: His Immigration plan.
While I might differ on the odd point or two, overall his plan actually makes sense. It treats the problem as a whole, and attacks it from all angles, n...
Republican National Convention Blog trackbacked with "Bloodrocuted"
Task Force 1-26 engaged in Operation Baton Rouge, the battle to free Samarra, tells of an electrician whose identity gets confused with that of a dangerous criminal, and is then found and chased through a forest by mercenaries.
Rosemary's Thoughts trackbacked with "The Conservative Voice News"
Permalink: http://rosemarysthoughts.blogspot.com/2007/10/conservative-voice-news.html
Trackback: http://haloscan.com/tb/rawtension/7892441668052391973
Open Trackback. Stop on over. Tonight's topic: The Conservative Voice News.
The Florida Masochist trackbacked with "The Knucklehead of the Day award"
Today's winner is Mark Waller.
The Florida Masochist trackbacked with "Florida the rules are different here Chapter CLVIII"
A 75-year-old man who is legally blind shoots an intruder in his home. Maybe Mr. Williams can give these Florida police a refresher firearms course. Isn't this a great state or what?
Rosemary's Thoughts trackbacked with "A mixture of news potpourri"
I stated this earlier but in case you missed it, I am going to clean out my emails now. Most of it is news, opinion, or politics. I hope you enjoy it. Permalink (URL): http://rosemarysthoughts.blogspot.com/2007/10/mixture-of-news-potpourri.html
Tra...
The World According To Carl trackbacked with "PhotoHunt 81: Pink"
The latest PhotoHunt category from tnchick.com is “Pink” which can be interpreted as one sees fit. This is a mystery photo. Click on it to see what it is.
Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Perri Nelson’s ...
The World According To Carl trackbacked with "The Office"
Actually this has nothing to do with the sitcom of the same name but the actual workspace in my new (just about 2 months) job. I actually share a cubicle with another person (she works the day shift; I work the night shift) and was allowed to decorate ...
Conservative Cat trackbacked with "I Can Understand the Cat Thing, but the Bit About the Cars Has to be a Joke"
A reader asked me to look at a Christian blog called The Christian View - British Baptists. At issue was an article about the satanic nature of cats. The article is, of course, nonsense. Not only does it refer to...
Woman Honor Thyself trackbacked with "CensoR T.V…like the good ole dayS"
“Just turn the TV off”, they shout. Ah yes.
Turn off the…billboards, the entire internet, the magazines stands, the window dressing at the mall……….and on and on and on.
...
Right Truth trackbacked with "Hate Crimes vs. Thought Crimes"
When I heard about H.R. 1955, I thought it was about hate crimes. I was wrong. It's about thought crimes. The latest anti-terrorism bill - presented by a Democrat, is H.R. 1955: Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism Prevention Act of
Stuck On Stupid trackbacked with "Terrorists Support Monica's Boyfriend's Wife For President"
Hillary & Yassir Arafat's wife, Suha
No surprise here, Islamic Fascists support Hillary Rodham Clinton for President.
This from Deroy Murdock :
Terrorists: Vote Hillary; Kill Rudy
«I hope Hillary is electe...
Subscribe to this entry's
comment feed. (Atom)
Angel responded with:
 | But the blame game is soooooo much easier Perri!..great thoughts and great insights on a difficult issue too ! |
Michael Parkatti responded with:
 | Yes, not enough attention is being paid to the global warming link -- and coupled with news of the Wild Pug population being threatened, this has been a busy week for environmental news:
http://www.humblenarrator.com/2007/10/30/wild-pug-habitat-threatened-due-to-global-warming/ |
Perri Nelson responded with:
 | Not enough attention is being paid the to global warming link? I'd say that too much emphasis is given to global warming as a "cause" or exacerbating factor in the California wildfires.
At least two of the fires were deliberately set by arsonists. As for the other wildfires, there is nothing unusual about them. California suffers wildfires every year.
Oh wait... you had me going there for a minute Michael...
I love that article on your site about the wild pug habitat being threatened. That just about says it all. |